Month: January 2009
How government created suburbia
‘Well-intentioned meddlers’
What will save the suburbs?
About four different readers pointed me to this intriguing blog posting at the New York Times by Allison Arieff, “What Will Save the Suburbs?”
I hope all our city council members, city staff, county commissioners, planning commissioners take time to read it. Arieff points out that unlike the development of the 19th and early 20th centuries, the postwar suburbia is going to be difficult to re-purpose (ugh, horrible word). Yet in Charlotte, you can still build a three-houses-per-acre single-family subdivision without any City Council rezoning needed — auto-pilot growth .
Empty big-box stores are just one of the problems. (I wonder if the book she cites, Julia Christensen’s “Big Box Reuse” mentions that one old K mart in Charlotte was reused as a charter school.)
The difficulty of re-purposing development that was badly designed to start with is one major hurdle for attracting any serious uptown retail: There simply aren’t enough good sidewalk-front spaces clumped together to attract enough stores. After all, retail loves to be near other retail. (See “shopping centers.”) If you don’t understand what I mean about good sidewalk-front spaces, take a field trip to downtown Asheville.
Maybe this development downturn will inspire the city of Charlotte to finally look with purpose at the kind of by-right development (meaning no rezoning needed) it’s allowing.
Did developers slow naming of CDOT director?
Let’s see, Charlotte Transportation Director Jim Humphrey left in late 2007. So why did it take until 2009 for the city to name a replacement? Today City Manager Curt Walton announced he was promoting Interim Director Danny Pleasant, who came to CDOT as deputy director in 2002.
A good source tells me one reason for the delay was nervousness in the development community about Pleasant, whose initiatives in the department have pushed the envelope for good community design. Apparently City Manager Curt Walton was able to get the City Council members comfortable with Pleasant as CDOT director.
As deputy director, he oversaw transportation planning that is putting more emphasis on walkable streets, bicycling paths, connectivity. One of his responsibilities was the six-years-in-the-making effort to rewrite the design guidelines under which streets widths and sidewalk widths and other such essential rules are written. Those urban street design guidelines came under criticism from the development community who didn’t like the requirements for wider planting strips, required street trees and shorter block lengths.
Pleasant has a master’s in urban planning, is a member of the Congress for the New Urbanism, the American Institute of Certified Planners and a fellow of the Institute of Transportation Engineers.
Is Charlotte getting dissed?
For those who think the Naked City is my only writing, here’s a link to my Saturday column, “Should the Queen City feel dissed?” It’s about Charlotte-Raleigh relations. I’ll blog more later today.
Calif. city manager: Scrap zoning
Rick Cole writes that zoning codes are the problem, not the solution, in the effort to build and maintain great cities. He writes:
“The American Dream” of single-family tracts, shopping centers and business parks owes more to zoning mandates than to market economics. Zoning was imposed on the American landscape by an unholy alliance between Utopians preaching a “modern” way of life and hard-headed businessmen who profited from supplying that new model, including an auto industry steeped in the ideology that “What’s good for General Motors is good for America.”
Cole is a former mayor of Pasadena, Calif., and now city manager in Ventura, Calif. Instead of zoning, he says, use “codes” — something more and more municipalities are doing. Then he has a good analysis of the terminology of “form-based-codes” (a cumbersome term that addresses the how, but not the why you’d have one) vs. “smart codes” (a term that’s been adopted by lots of developers whose projects were anything but smart).
A number of smaller municipalities in this region have adopted codes that are akin to the form-based code. Charlotte isn’t one of them.
Build roads, repair roads or fund transit?
There’s plenty of chatter about whether federal economic stimulus money should go for transit, for road-building, for repairs or building new. But there’s also a big push to target the about-to-be-written federal transportation bill. A coalition group called Transportation for America is warning: ”Now is not the time to squander money on projects or plans that do not help save Americans money, free us from oil dependence and create long-term jobs.” Here’s a link to a blog item on it from Smart Growth Online. It quotes an Associated Press article:
”Now is not the time to squander money on projects or plans that do not help save Americans money, free us from oil dependence and create long-term jobs,” warns a diverse Transportation for America coalition of environmental, urban design, housing and other groups, launching a campaign to make sure the 2009 federal transportation bill allocates a fair share for mass transit and infrastructure repair instead of funding mostly new roads, reports Associated Press writer Sarah Karush. The effort [has been] joined by Pennsylvania and Virginia Democratic Governors Ed Rendell and Timothy M. Kaine, and former Maryland Democratic Governor Parris N. Glendening, now the Smart Growth Leadership Institute president.
”That’s always difficult politically,” said Governor Rendell about his state’s fix-it-first approach, but recalling the deadly August 2007 collapse of the I-35W Mississippi River Bridge in Minneapolis, he asked, ”How many more Minnesotas do we have to have as a country?”
Governor Kaine cited a decline in vehicle miles traveled (VMT) and an increase in transit demand, telling the writer, ”The key is to provide choices, so you invest in everything.” And Governor Glendening said, ”Make sure that infrastructure really builds for the future. That’s about transit, that’s about walkability, that’s about ‘fix it first.’ ”
No crime ‘czar’ but guess what!
Here’s the article from today’s paper explaining what was about to happen. If April Bethea (who’s sitting next to me here in the front row) posts a new story I’ll add a newer link.
Hot air about saving farmland?
Commissioners Dan Murrey and Dumont Clarke now talking about promoting local food, and preserving farms.