Update on Thursday, Aug. 27: I have a request from reporter Ann Doss Helms: She’s trying to find parents of kids who’d be switched from the Myers Park High School attendance zone to East Mecklenburg. Would the person who left the comment on that effect – or anyone else in that category – please contact her at ahelms@charlotteobserver.com or at 704-358-5033? She wants to hear from people on all sides of the issue.
The comment thread about Best Cities for Kids took an interesting turn last night and this morning. Take a look (link).
Several commenters made the valid point that the U.S. News & World Report rankings appeared to favor relatively affluent, mostly white suburban-ish areas with well-funded schools and low crime. “White flight” someone said, shouldn’t be rewarded.
Indeed, I believe a community with many different ethnicities is a lot more interesting, and I agree that the rankings look as if they hadn’t taken into account the reality that an affluent suburb is probably going to compare well for schools and crime stats. One commenter said, “Diversity is a city like Charlotte that has a 33% black population, a large Hispanic population, and a large white population. That in itself presents quite a challenge.”
Then faithful reader/commenter “Cato” brought up Robert Putnam, a Harvard professor. His recent studies have shown that as ethnic diversity in an area rises, social trust goes down. This is true, he says, for all races and ethnicities. I’ve heard him lecture on this phenomenon several times, and each time he said he didn’t like getting those results and kept double-checking his data and coming up with the same result.
So whoever thinks Cato is misquoting Putnam is off-base.
But I think Cato, too, is off-base in saying, “Why is this [less social trust] a desirable trait in a city? Especially if you get more crime and worse schools in the bargain? Or is it that the intangible benefits of white liberal self-congratulation are enough to coutnerbalance it?”
Putnam thinks it’s a good idea to be aware of the tendency toward lower social trust and figure out how to counteract it. To say, “Especially if you get more crime and worse schools in the bargain,” seems to me to ignore some realities:
One: Bernie and his hedge fund ilk as well as all the toxic loan purveyors and mortgage fraud perps have proved there’s plenty of crime in rich areas too, and it’s certainly not “victimless.” It’s not someone taking your CD player. They’re taking your investments, or driving up your taxes by not paying theirs, or destroying the companies in which you own stock. I’d rather have my car stolen than the worth of my 401(k).
Two: Poverty correlates with higher crime, no question. Yet to say that you get “more crime” when a city area is more ethnically and economically integrated might really mean “more crime where I live in what used to be an all white, all middle-class area.” The crime is already there, and many low-income people suffer horribly from it.
Three: “Worse schools.” Again, the kids with the bad teachers, crappy home lives and falling down schools are already out there, so racial and ethnic and economic mixing doesn’t cause those problems, but rather brings them to the attention of people heretofore not having to deal with them.
White flight – or to be more accurate, wealthy and “bright” flight – makes public schools worse, as parents with time, means and enthusiasm to help the schools disappear from the support base. That leaves schools with disproportionately more kids from bad situations, and fewer parents able and willing to fight for better resources. So more of the parents who care about their kids’ school then leave, which causes a downward spiral. But it isn’t as if racial/ethnic diversity by itself “causes” bad schools, rather the effects of people fleeing the effects of poverty can cause schools to start spiralling downward.
But Cato’s right in saying that an economically and ethnically integrated city will indeed have to deal with those problems more than a bedroom community of affluent educated residents.
And for the record, I’m a proud parent of a high school senior who’s been at CMS since kindergarten and has top-notch schooling at Charlotte’s racially and ethnically diverse public schools. Many CMS schools are excellent, safe and well-run. And yes, some aren’t. But just because you see some brown faces doesn’t automatically mean the school’s a bad place for your child.
