Thank you, anonymous commenter from 5:20 p.m. Tuesday. I am not against density or height. I am against height in the wrong place. You can make a case that next door to the Arlington is an appropriate spot for density, and I won’t get in your face about it, although I think the proximity to the Dilworth Historic District makes it problematic, for reasons I’ve mentioned before. Overall, I tend to agree with Charleston Mayor Joe Riley, who says that six five-story buildings are better than one 30-story building.
But here’s the crux of my objections to the South End rezoning: The whole point of a small station area plan is to plan what heights and densities are appropriate on which spots. If the planners who wrote the South End Station Area Plan and the City Council who adopted it in 2005 believed that site was appropriate for buildings twice the height of the rest of the area’s height limit, why not have the plan say that? Why limit the appropriate height there, in the plan, to 120 feet? Those kinds of issues are precisely why your tax money pays for planners and why your elected representatives adopt small area plans.
Why even bother with any plan if it’s routinely disregarded?
It reminds me of taking a kid to the grocery store. You say before you go, “I’m not buying you candy in the check-out line.” If you then buy the kid a Snickers in the check-out line, that kid will cry for candy on every visit to the store for the next 20 years. And you will have undermined any credibility your authority might have had.
One last thing, responding to a commenter on the post about the Piedmont Town Center project: I LOVE Filene’s Basement. Offer one of those up and I’ll be out there with my chainsaw. (Joke, people, joke.)