On to other topics, as I see not many of you were interested in the Modernism versus New Urbanism article. I do recommend, however, reading the 11/27/06 comment about Marianne Cusato’s experience with post-Katrina plans and the audience rising up to oppose a Modernist design being imposed upon them. (Even I concede that when Solomon’s talk was presented as a speech and slide show, my own attention span wore about after about an hour.)
Today, during a briefing from Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools Superintendent Peter Gorman on his Strategic Plan 2010 (I’ll reserve comment until it’s unveiled tomorrow) I found, deep in my legal pad, notes I apparently scribbled to myself during some other meeting at some other time.
It appears to be observations about planning and growth in Charlotte and this region. Thoughts? Put ’em below.
1. Are city plans worthless?
– The incredible weakness of planning. Plans are timid – rarely push against development in the works.– Worse, city policy – adopted after developer pressure – guts them. The rezoning-changes-the-plan rule. [That refers to the nutso policy of City Council, whereby any vote for a rezoning that doesn’t conform to the adopted plan magically alters the adopted plan so that, voila, the new zoning now becomes part of the plan. It’s a travesty.]
– Council, even staff, frequently won’t support [plans]. (See above.), Plus lack of money for enough staff.
2. Developers– Not monolithic. [I meant there are many developers, and they’re not all alike and don’t all share the same views.]
– Change the rules. If you keep on doing what you’ve always done, etc.
– The lying. [I meant here, that some developers – not all – tell lies, either to neighbors or to elected officials.]
3. No hope for real regional planning without state involvement.
4. State legislature major hypocrite. “Land use is local” excuse. But won’t give localities authority for such land use tools as impact fees, etc.
5. Follow the money. Even if Mark Felt never said it. [Felt was Watergate’s Deep Throat.]
6. Traffic congestion is inevitable. “Congestion is the condition of the city.”
[That’s a quote from architect and planner Andres Duany, one of the founders of the New Urbanist movement. His point: It’s in the nature of cities to be crowded. You can’t cure congestion in a city.]